So, Werit asked what people thought about Guild Taxes and Tithes (which is part of the living guild system found in WAR).
I’m for the idea of tithing moreso taxing. Giving something to the guild should be a voluntary action that each member of the guild should partake in. This also lets officers see who is more of a team player by who is contributing to the guild coffers to help with guild purchases and such.
Taxes are just intrusive, although I could agree with it if it was something reasonable (10%). Anything more than that would seem a bit high to me.